Reviews

Men's Rogue Fly™

Average Rating

(5)
5 stars
(4)
4 stars
(0)
3 stars
(0)
2 stars
(1)
1 star
(0)

Average Fit

Runs Small
True to Size
Runs Large

URPEric

Sacramento, CA
Nov 27, 2012

Great transition/hybrid shoe

Since I’ve been wearing normal drop shoes and lamenting the cancellation of the Brooks Green Silence (one of my favorite all time shoes), I went on a search for a trail/hybrid version of my beloved GS. My criteria was simple: Hybrid design for road/trail, lightweight, and a moderate drop (6-10mm). Here’s what I found in the Montrail Rogue Fly. The design. Built very much like the Green Silence, the seamless Rogue Fly has a 10mm drop which scared me at first, coming from a zero drop SKORA or my 8mm Green Silences. A seamless and very thin upper is made from what appears to be the same material as the Brooks and an open lacing design is reminiscent as well. All in all, a good looking shoe, although the MONTRAIL letters on the side is a bit obnoxious. Weight. This thing is light! My size 12 Green Silence weigh 9 1/4 oz, while these beauties come in at 9 5/8 oz, an almost imperceptible

Fit
Runs Small
True to Size
Runs Large



Arnaldo

Indianapolis, IN
Oct 26, 2012

Great Trail Shoe

This shoe was amazing right out of the box. The fit was great. Because it a minimally constructed trail shoe its light and hugs the foot well. With 10 mm drop its just right to blast on downhills and still work on uphills. I use to run in minimal shoes (i.e. barefoot) but I couldn't use them on trails for very long. This shoe is the best of both worlds. Minimal enough for me with just enough cushion. They fell good on roads, surprisingly, but I wouldn't recommend to do all road miles in these. The colors look great in person too. All around a solid shoe that I would highly recommend. I tried on the rogue racer and it bothered how it fit around my toes and these just worked perfect.

Fit
Runs Small
True to Size
Runs Large



GoAway

Jackson, WY
Oct 6, 2012

Not quite "neutral"

I wanted to love this shoe, but I had a few complaints and will be returning. This is allegedly a neutral running shoe, however a 10mm drop is pretty substantial for a "neutral" shoe (IMO). I also found these shoes to run a little bit small (slightly less than a half size) and very narrow. If you have a wider foot these will not work well at all. The forefoot is especially narrow, which is problematic for those who are used to running barefoot or have used other minimal shoes (not saying any names). I have been running barefoot for a few years now and found these shoes just wouldn't work. I have a friend who loves them however, he just doesn't run barefoot at all and has a slightly narrow foot. I'm not saying they're a bad shoe, just not for me - or anyone with a wider forefoot. If you're looking for something really neutral, look elsewhere.

Fit
Runs Small
True to Size
Runs Large



Lately1980

Boulder, CO
Jun 1, 2012

Worthy of an award

I originally read about these shoes in Outside Magazine and they have definitely lived up to the hype. I've been running in these for the last few weeks and I've never worn a more comfortable trail running shoe. For your longer trail runs, you won't find a better ride.

Fit
Runs Small
True to Size
Runs Large



JohnnyTah

San Francisco, CA
Jun 1, 2012

Incredible!

What a great minimalist running shoe! These shoes are everything I've been looking for and haven't been able to find anywhere else. It barely feels like you have anything on when you run in these. I would highly recommend these to anyone in the minimalist trail running market. Nice work Montrail!

Fit
Runs Small
True to Size
Runs Large